Skip to main content Skip to navigation

Economic Feasibility of Anaerobic Digester Systems with Nutrient Recovery Technologies

Economic Feasibility of Anaerobic Digester Systems with Nutrient Recovery Technologies

Suzette Galinato, School of Economic Sciences, Washington State University, Chad Kruger, Center for Sustaining Agriculture and Natural Resources, Washington State University, Craig Frear, Center for Sustaining Agriculture and Natural Resources, Washington State University
Anaerobic digesters are used worldwide to produce bioenergy and sustainably treat organic waste from municipal, industrial, and agricultural operations. This publication analyzes the economic feasibility of three nutrient recovery technologies that work in tandem with anaerobic digester systems. The Anaerobic Digestion Systems Series provides research based information to improve decision-making for incorporating, augmenting, and maintaining anaerobic digestion systems for manures and food by-products.
Section 3 Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Mauris sit amet pulvinar massa, vel suscipit turpis. Vestibulum sollicitudin felis sit amet mi luctus, sed malesuada nibh ultricies. Nam sit amet accumsan dui, vitae placerat tortor. Vestibulum facilisis fermentum dignissim. Maecenas ultrices cursus diam, eu volutpat urna viverra non.




This Washington State University (WSU) Extension publication is an abbreviated review of information contained in the Renewable Natural Gas and Nutrient Recovery Feasibility for DeRuyter Dairy (Coppedge et al. 2012). It is part of the Anaerobic Digestion Systems Series, which aims to provide information that improves decision-making for anaerobic digestion systems. Readers interested in further details are encouraged to read the full WSU report. Furthermore, individuals interested in a specific digester installation should seek expert guidance from an Anaerobic Digestion System technology provider. The US EPA­AgSTAR project database contains a list of technology providers across the country.

This publication introduces key concerns regarding nutrient management. It discusses and compares the profitability of three nutrient recovery technologies that work in tandem with anaerobic digester systems. While one of the nutrient technologies was developed in collaboration with WSU, this publication does not intend to promote the WSU­patented technology. Rather, the emphases are on the technology’s process of removing nutrients from dairy waste and an examination of its contribution to the profitability of an anaerobic digestion project compared to current alternatives.

Nutrient Management

Nutrient management is one of the most important concerns identified by dairy owners that can potentially have negative economic impacts (Bishop and Shumway 2009). Every year, a dairy cow generates 164 kg total nitrogen, 80 kg total ammonia nitrogen, and 28 kg total phosphorus (ASAE 2005). The microbial breakdown of manure can emit ammonia and other compounds that cause concerns in air quality and respiratory health (Archibeque et al. 2007; Erisman and Schaap 2004; McCubbin et al. 2002), as well as methane, which is a potent greenhouse gas (Shih et al. 2006). Meanwhile, long-term manure application on agricultural lands may result in excess nitrogen and phosphorus accumulation, which has contributed to problems with nitrate leaching, eutrophication, ammonia toxicity, and nitrate-induced blue baby syndrome (EPA 1996).

As a result of these concerns, a number of efforts to develop and commercialize nutrient recovery technologies appropriate for dairies and other livestock operations are underway. This publication focuses on the economic feasibility of nutrient recovery technologies that work in tandem with anaerobic

digester systems. These technologies essentially recover phosphorus and nitrogen from used water streams, such as dairy waste, and transform the recovered nutrients into fertilizer. The rationale for nutrient recovery and a description of specific nutrient recovery technologies are covered more fully by Yorgey et al. (2013).

Anaerobic Digestion and Nutrient Recovery Technologies

Anaerobic digestion (AD) creates an anaerobic environment (without oxygen) in which naturally occurring microorganisms convert complex organic materials in manure and other wet organic wastes, such as food processing wastes, to biogas. Biogas can be used in a combined heat and power (CHP) model to generate renewable energy, or it can be further refined to renewable natural gas (RNG) which can be used as a transportation fuel. In addition to biogas, AD creates many co­benefits, including reductions in greenhouse gas emissions, decreased odors, waste stabilization, and lower pathogen counts (EPA 2004; EPA 2005; EPA 2008; Martin and Roos 2007).

Coppedge et al. (2012) examined an anaerobic digester in the Yakima Valley that processes feedstock from 5,000 dairy cows, generating 165,000 gallons of concentrated manure per day. Little to no off­farm materials are fed into the digester. The study looks at different configurations of AD projects. The current baseline is an AD­CHP system and has been operational since 2008. This system produces biogas that fuels a modified diesel engine and generator, which then produces electricity and recovered heat. The electrical power is sold to the grid. The initial capital cost for an AD­CHP system is approximately $4.4 million.

The second AD project is an investment scenario where biogas produced by the anaerobic digester is upgraded to RNG. The AD­RNG system is assumed to start producing renewable fuel two years after development of the infrastructure. The AD­RNG system is evaluated here under the scenario wherein the current AD­CHP is converted to this particular system (i.e., in 2012). The estimated total capital cost is $10.1 million, comprised of the initial investment for the AD­CHP ($4.4 million) plus a $5.7 million investment to convert the existing system and construct the infrastructure needed to produce renewable fuel. The RNG infrastructure includes a gas cleaning unit, digester modification for accepting non­manure inputs such as food processing substrates, transportation of gas off site via pipeline to an injection point, and a fueling station.



Copyright 2016 Washington State University

WSU Extension bulletins contain material written and produced for public distribution. Alternate formats of our educational materials are available upon request for persons with disabilities. Please contact Washington State University Extension for more information

Issued by Washington State University Extension and the U.S. Department of Agriculture in furtherance of the Acts of May 8 and June 30, 1914. Extension programs and policies are consistent with federal and state laws and regulations on nondiscrimination regarding race, sex, religion, age, color, creed, and national or ethnic origin; physical, mental, or sensory disability; marital status or sexual orientation; and status as a Vietnam-era or disabled veteran. Evidence of noncompliance may be reported through your local WSU Extension office. Trade names have been used to simplify information; no endorsement is intended.